At a 3 to 15 person agency, the next client is often a current one
For an agency of 3 to 15 people, growth usually means a new logo. One agency advisor puts the target the other way around: most new revenue in a year should come from clients already on the books. Few agencies get there. The ones that try need two lists: what each client might buy next, and which clients should not be sold anything more.
Third-party data
- By Vinicius Diniz
- Published October 30, 2026
- Methodology
How much new revenue comes from current clients?
The target one agency advisor sets is 70% of new revenue from existing clients. What agencies report is far from it: in a survey of 778 agency leaders, 7% said they are extremely effective at getting existing clients to spend more each year.
70%of new revenue in any given year should come from existing clients, in Drew McLellan's target. A target, not a measurement.
Source: Drew McLellan, Agency Management Institute, Build a Better Agency podcast, episode 50, September 19, 2016. See all benchmarks
7%of agencies say they are extremely effective at getting existing clients to increase spending year over year.
Source: Agency Management Institute, The 2025 Agency Core Research Report, 778 agency leaders, November 13 to December 31, 2024. See all benchmarks
The same report found that 68% of agencies lost clients in the previous year. Growing current clients and keeping them are the same conversation: the client who buys a second service has one more reason to stay.
If your agency has never sold a second service to a current client on purpose, you are where most agencies are.
Diagnose: is there anything they would buy?
Three questions, one current client at a time. Each answer is yes or no.
- In the last year, has this client asked whether you do something you do, or hired someone else for it? If yes, the demand already exists and nobody answered it.
- Can you state this client's main business goal for this year in one sentence, in their words? If not, any offer will sound like your goal, not theirs. In Setup's 2025 survey of brands and agencies, 44% of clients who ended a relationship said the agency did not understand their business.
- Does this client make money for you today? If you don't know, check before offering anything (next section).
The math: growing the book against winning a new client
Growing an 11-client book by 10% a year adds more revenue than one new client at the same average retainer, without a pitch. The numbers below are a planning example.
Assumptions
- Current clientsPlanning assumption
- 11
- Average retainerThe planning example used across this site
- $6,800 a month
- Growth of the bookMcLellan's reasonable minimum expectation for account managers; a guideline
- 10% a year
- Clients adding one servicePlanning assumption
- 3 at $1,500 a month
Result
- Annual revenue: 11 × $6,800 × 12
- $897,600
- Growing that book by 10% in a year
- $89,760
- One new client at the same retainer, full first year: $6,800 × 12
- $81,600
- Another way to cover part of it: 3 × $1,500 × 12
- $54,000
The $6,800 retainer is the same planning example as the cold referral cost calculator.
- Grow the book 10%
- One new client
- 3 clients add a service
Planning example. Higher means more new revenue in the first year.
The point is not that one replaces the other. A new client takes a referral, a proposal and weeks of selling. A second service to a current client takes one conversation with someone who already trusts the work.
When selling more loses money
Selling more to the wrong client costs more than it brings. In a study of five firms in consumer and business markets, 10% to 35% of customers who bought across product lines were unprofitable, and they accounted for 39% to 88% of the firms' losses from customers.
Third-party data Not agencies
Source: Shah, Kumar, Qu and Chen, "Unprofitable Cross-Buying: Evidence from Consumer and Business Markets," Journal of Marketing, 2012. Customer databases of five firms; consumer and business markets, not agencies.
The study tied the losses to persistent behaviors: customers who kept spending small amounts, returned purchases, demanded more service, or bought mostly on promotion. The agency version is familiar: the client who already takes more hours than the retainer pays for.
Be sure that anything you recommend is, indeed, in the client's interest.
Source: Sakas & Company, Agency marketing: what to do when your referrals dry up, March 16, 2026.
Before offering anything, run the client through the client hours calculator. If a client's margin is already below what the agency needs, the second service usually adds hours to the same problem.
Where to keep the list
The list needs one line per current client and a date to raise it. A spreadsheet works. If the agency already uses a CRM for new business, a second pipeline for current-client opportunities keeps the two from mixing. In HubSpot, additional deal pipelines take a paid subscription (Vendor spec, HubSpot developer documentation, checked October 30, 2026).
The same weekly 15 minutes from the 15-minute referral system covers it: one line under each current client, every week.
When not to grow a current client
Skip the offer, or fix something else first, in these cases:
- The client's margin is below 10%. Agency Management Institute's Drew McLellan sets 10% as his floor (
I don't think a client that is less than 10% profitable is a client that deserves to be in your shop.
) and says the right number varies by agency. Fix the price or the scope before adding work. - The client has complained about delivery in the last quarter. A second service gives them a second thing to be disappointed by. See how long clients stay at small agencies for why delivery is the reason clients give for leaving.
- You would deliver the new service through a contractor you haven't worked with. The trust you are using is in your work, not theirs.
- The client asked for a discount in the last six months. That is close to buying on promotion, one of the behaviors the study tied to losses.
Source: Agency Management Institute, 5 key agency metrics, March 30, 2020.
The one-afternoon list
List every current client with one line each, and pick one conversation to have this month.
- Write each client's main business goal for this year, in one sentence.
- Next to it, write one problem close to that goal that the agency already solves for someone else.
- Mark each client's margin as known or unknown. For unknown, run the client hours calculator first.
- Pick the one client with a known healthy margin and the clearest problem. Ask for 20 minutes about their goal, not about your service.
More on pipeline and referrals for agencies of 3 to 15 people, with every sourced number in the benchmarks behind this site.
Sources
- Agency Management Institute, The 2025 Agency Core Research Report (778 agency leaders, November 13 to December 31, 2024). Accessed October 30, 2026.
- Drew McLellan, Sustaining Your Business Through New Business, Build a Better Agency podcast, episode 50, September 19, 2016. Accessed October 30, 2026.
- Setup, The 2025 Marketing Relationship Survey Results, January 27, 2026. Accessed October 30, 2026.
- Shah, D., Kumar, V., Qu, Y., and Chen, S. Unprofitable Cross-Buying: Evidence from Consumer and Business Markets, Journal of Marketing, 2012 (publisher abstract). Accessed October 30, 2026.
- Karl Sakas, Agency marketing: what to do when your referrals dry up, Sakas & Company, originally published January 23, 2017, revised March 16, 2026. Accessed October 30, 2026.
- Drew McLellan, 5 key agency metrics, Agency Management Institute, January 6, 2017, revised March 30, 2020. Accessed October 30, 2026.
- HubSpot, Pipelines, developer documentation, checked October 30, 2026. Accessed October 30, 2026.